organic chemistry - If SOCl2 reacts with alcohols via SNi, why doesn't POCl3?

A bit of a follow-up to Why is thionyl chloride preferred for preparing alkyl chlorides from alcohols?.

---

The reaction with $\ce{SOCl2}$ is also used instead of $\ce{PCl3}$ and $\ce{PCl5}$ when retention of stereochemistry is required. Phosphorus trichloride and phosphorus pentachloride both lead to inversion.

The mechanism proceeds via a $\mathrm{SN_i}$ pathway, or internal nucleophilic substitution. This step has been highlighed in red; an intimate ion pair$^{[\text{see below}]}$ is given in square brackets. Adding a nucleophilic solvent such as pyridine considerably increases inversion with $\ce{SOCl2}$ via an attack at the sulfur atom. Green marks blocking of the intramolecular substitution; blue is for inversion.

---

• As far as I know, $\ce{POCl3}$ has not been seen following an $\mathrm{SN_i}$ mechanism (even without pyridine). Why?

If possible, please provide a qualitative mechanistic reason. Something that is readily explained by waving hands. Regardless of whether such an approach is achievable, quantitative (calculational) answers are also most welcome.

---

References discussing intimate ion pair formation

• F. A. Carey, R. J. Sundberg. $(2007)$. Advanced Organic Chemistry Part A: Structure and Mechanisms, $4$th edition, pp 269$-$276. ISBN: 0-306-46242-7


• W. A. Hughes, E. D. Cowdrey, C. K. Ingold, S. Masterman, A. D. Scott. 'The Mechanism of Elimination Reactions. Part 1. Unimolecular Olefin Formation from Alkyl Halides in Bulphur Dioxide and Formic Acid'. Journal of the Chemical Society, $(1937)$, 1271$-$1277. DOI: 10.1039/JR9370001271


• E. S. Lewis, C. E. Boozer. 'The Kinetics and Stereochemistry of the Decomposition of Secondary Alkyl Chlorosulfites'. Journal of the American Chemical Society, $(1952)$, 74, 308$-$311. DOI: 10.1021/ja01122a005


• D. J. Cram. 'Studies in Stereochemistry. XVI. Ionic Intermediates in the Decomposition of Certain Alkyl Chlorosulfites'. Journal of the American Chemical Society, $(1953)$, 75, 332$-$338. DOI: 10.1021/ja01098a024


• C. C. Lee, A. J. Finlayson. 'Rearrangement In The Reaction Between Thionyl Chloride And $3$-Methyl-$2$-Butanol. Canadian Journal of Chemistry, $(1961)$, 39(1): 260$-$261. DOI: 10.1139/v61-030


• C. C. Lee, J. W. Clayton, D. G. Lee, A. J. Finlayson. 'Rearrangement Studies With $\ce{^14C-XIII}$: The Thermal Decomposition Of $1$-$\ce{^14C}$-$2$-Butyl Chlorosulfite'. Tetrahedron, $(1962)$, 18 1395$-$1402. DOI: 10.1021/ja01098a024


• H. Patin, G. Mignani, C. Mahe, J-Y. Le Marouille, A. Benoit, D. Grandjean. 'Ferrocenyltrithiocarbonates: I. Direct access from α-ferrocenylcarbinols by a $\mathrm{SN_i}$ mechanism. Absolute x-ray structure determination of (R)-ferrocenylmethylmethane S-methyl-trithiocarbonate'. Journal of Organometallic Chemistry, $(1980)$, 193, 1, 93$-$103. DOI: 10.1016/S0022-328X(00)86079-9


• J. L. Kice, G. C. Hanson. 'Mechanisms of SNi reactions. Effect of aralkyl group structure on ion-pair return in the decomposition of aralkyl thiocarbonates'. Journal of the American Chemical Society, $(1973)$, 38 (7), 1410$-$1415. DOI: 10.1021/jo00947a037



• M. B. Smith. $(2013)$. March's Advanced Organic Chemistry: Reactions, Mechanisms, and Structure, $7$th edition, pp 311, 486$-$487, 490, 598, 1316. ISBN: 978-0-470-46259-1


• _{The $\mathrm{SN_i}$ (substitution nucleophilic internal) mechanism: retention of configuration. Powerpoint presentation, Università degli Studi di Napoli Federico II.}


• _{James. $\ce{SOCl2}$ and the $\mathrm{SN_i}$ Mechanism. Master Organic Chemistry, Alcohols. webpage}