Tuesday, 7 June 2016

halacha - Borer and Grinding on Yom Tov - and other Melachoth that are Ochel Nefesh


Which Melachoth are prohibited on Shabbath but are permissible to perform on Yom Tov because of the exception of Ochel Nefesh? Famously, cooking and carrying in the public domain are allowed, yet igniting a flame from scratch is not. Furthermore, some other actions that would seem to be Ochel Nefesh are also prohibited. What else is allowed? Are Sorting and Grinding on the list?


I am also fairly certain that there's a difference between Ashkenazi practice and Sepharadi practice in some instances. Please provide sources for each.


(Please don't list smoking as permitted as cooking but should be prohibited because of danger, or other such exceptions to the exceptions. I'm looking for general categories of Melachah, not unique subcategories or specific types of actions. If a category is permitted only under certain circumstances, such as squeezing a lemon on a solid but not into a liquid, which is permissible on Shabbath anyway, that should be noted.)




Answer




  1. Zoreah (Sowing) - forbidden

  2. Choresh (Plowing) - forbidden

  3. Kotzair (Reaping) - forbidden

  4. M'amair (Gathering) - forbidden

  5. Dush (Threshing) – forbidden

  6. Zoreh (Winnowing) - forbidden

  7. Borer (Sorting ) – [generally] permitted

  8. Tochain (Grinding) – forbidden


  9. Miraked (Sifting) - forbidden

  10. Lush (Kneading) - permitted

  11. Ofeh / Bishul (Baking/cooking) - permitted

  12. Gozez (Shearing) - forbidden

  13. Melabain (Whitening) - forbidden

  14. Menafetz (Disentangling, Combing) - forbidden

  15. Tzovayah (Dyeing) – forbidden

  16. Toveh (Spinning) - forbidden

  17. Maisach (Mounting the warp) - forbidden

  18. Oseh Beit Batai Neirin (Setting two heddles) - forbidden


  19. Oraig (Weaving) - forbidden

  20. Potzai'ah (Separating threads) - forbidden

  21. Koshair (Tying a knot) - forbidden

  22. Matir (Untying a knot) - forbidden

  23. Tofair (Sewing) – forbidden

  24. Ko'reah (Tearing) - forbidden

  25. Tzud (Trapping) - forbidden

  26. Shochet (Slaughtering) - permitted

  27. Mafshit (Skinning) - permitted

  28. M'abaid (Salting/tanning process) - permitted


  29. Mesharteit (Tracing lines) - forbidden

  30. Memacheik (Smoothing / scraping) - forbidden

  31. Mechateich (Cutting to shape) - forbidden

  32. Kotaiv (Writing two or more letters) - forbidden

  33. Mochaik (Erasing two or more letters) - forbidden

  34. Boneh (Building) - forbidden

  35. Soiser (Demolishing) - forbidden

  36. Mechabeh (Extinguishing) – only for actual “ochel nefesh”

  37. Ma'avir (Kindling) – permitted

  38. Makeh B'Patish (Striking the final blow) – forbidden


  39. Hotza'ah – (Transferring from domain to domain) - permitted


(Based on the first chapter of Nitey Gavriel Hilchos Yom Tov (Chelek Aleph). List of melachos from here).


No comments:

Post a Comment

readings - Appending 内 to a company name is read ない or うち?

For example, if I say マイクロソフト内のパートナーシップは強いです, is the 内 here read as うち or ない? Answer 「内」 in the form: 「Proper Noun + 内」 is always read 「ない...