Sunday, 10 January 2016

reference request - Conductivity as a function of acid concentration


I have conducted an experiment measuring the conductivity of both hydrochloric acid and sulfuric acid in solution respectively, with varying concentration. Wikipedia as well as a question on the site suggests a $\sqrt{c}$ relationship is viable. However, my data resembles this:


enter image description here


Clearly not a simple $\sqrt{c}$. It reminds me of the inverse gamma distribution. I have tried looking at papers by Onsager on his conductivity theory, but they're unclear, and he doesn't propose a function. Are there any papers that look at accurately modelling conductivity as a function of concentration which exhibit this form? Obviously for low concentrations (e.g. 1-2 molar), a linear or $\sqrt{c}$ would suffice.



Answer



At low concentration, conductivity is proportional to concentration (a linear relationship).


Each ion will have its own unique mobility, as discovered by Kohlrausch. $\ce{H+}$ has the highest mobility. As you can see in your graph the acids have higher conductivities than the salts. $\ce{OH-}$ is also highly mobile. As concentration increases, the linear relationship breaks down for two reasons.


Firstly, in infinitely dilute solution, for the strong electrolytes in the graph, there is complete dissociation into separately solvated ions. However, as concentration increases, a portion of the electrolyte exists as ion pairs. See for example Equations for Densities and Dissociation Constant of NaCl(aq) at 25°C from “Zero to Saturation” Based on Partial Dissociation J. Electrochem. Soc. 1997 vol. 144, pp. 2380-2384.


Secondly, the mobility of the ions that are solvated is decreased by the fact that they are no longer moving through water, but are instead moving past other ions as well.


To have a maximum in the curves of the question, and to account for the above factors, it is necessary to subtract a term from the linear term.



You need a function of the form:


$$\text{Conductivity} = Ac - Bf(c),$$


where $A$ and $B$ are constants, $c$ is concentration, and $f(c)$ is some function of concentration. Historically, the function $Ac - Bc\sqrt{c}$ was the first and most simple to use.


I would start by trying to fit your data to that function.


More advanced treatments replace $\sqrt{c}$ with $\sqrt{I}$, where I is ionic strength. Further advances involve higher order $I$ in addition to $\sqrt{I}$, such as $I \ln (I)$, $I$, and $I^{3/2}$.


The $I \ln (I)$ and $I$ terms arise upon considering the ions as charged spheres of finite diameter, rather than a simple point charges, as explained in Electrolytic Conductance and Conductances of the Halogen Acids in Water and references cited therein. This is the reference to look at if you want the best function to fit the HCl curve in your graph as it includes numerical coefficients.


For more information see The Conductivity of Liquids by Olin Freeman Tower, which although not the most recent work, has the advantage of being understandable, or Calculating the conductivity of natural waters.


For a very advanced consideration, see "Electrical conductance of electrolyte mixtures of any type" Journal of Solution Chemistry, 1978, vol. 7, pp. 533-548.


No comments:

Post a Comment

readings - Appending 内 to a company name is read ない or うち?

For example, if I say マイクロソフト内のパートナーシップは強いです, is the 内 here read as うち or ない? Answer 「内」 in the form: 「Proper Noun + 内」 is always read 「ない...