Monday, 31 August 2015

grammar - How to denote the object and the subject of potential form verbs clearly?


The source in where I studied told me that you mark the object of potential form with が particle instead of を particle because potential form is just a state, no actual action is taken. It specifically told me that を can be used but が is better. I know how to make sentences where I'm the subject. 山が登れない : I can't climb the mountain. 彼が言っていることが聞こえない : I can't hear what he is saying. But what if I want to say "He can't eat apples" or "Alice can't go to school" or even "Bob can't kill Tanaka". With が、を、は I could be mistaken in saying "Tanaka can't kill Bob" instead of "Bob can't kill Tanaka". Can が also denote the subject or only the object?



Answer



The particle you are looking for is に.




He can't eat apples.

≒ 彼はりんごを食べられない。
≒ 彼にりんごは食べられない。


Bob can't kill Tanaka.
≒ ボブは田中を殺せない。
≒ ボブに田中は殺せない。


He can't climb this mountain.
≒ 彼はこの山を登れない。
≒ 彼にこの山は登れない。


the reason why he can't climb this mountain
≒ 彼がこの山を登れない理由

≒ 彼にこの山が登れない理由


He can't hear what I am saying.
≒ 彼に私が言っていることは聞こえない。
≒ 彼に私の言っていることは聞こえない。 (ga-no conversion)


Alice can't go to school.
アリスは学校に行けない。
(You cannot say アリスに学校に行けない. Probably because there is already に?)



(Different words are topicalized using は, but I don't know which is "better"...)


EDIT: changed the fifth example above for consistency.



No comments:

Post a Comment

readings - Appending 内 to a company name is read ない or うち?

For example, if I say マイクロソフト内のパートナーシップは強いです, is the 内 here read as うち or ない? Answer 「内」 in the form: 「Proper Noun + 内」 is always read 「ない...