Sunday, 28 February 2016

Why do strong acids have weak conjugate bases?


This question is based on the Brønsted-Lowry model. I saw many answers to similar questions online. However none of them have given a detailed answer that is based on molecular structure (the answers all told the OP to rely on a reference table for a way to identify strong and weak acids).



Answer



All chemical processes are reversible at least to some extent.



Keeping this in mind, a strong acid must have a weak conjugate base (I think you mean strong acids have weak conjugate bases).


Why? Let's try to prove by contradiction. If a strong acid had a strong conjugate base, then the base would quickly re-associate itself with a hydrogen proton. This reverses what the acid just did - dissociate itself from a hydrogen proton!


To illustrate this concept, consider hydrochloric acid - the oft-cited strong acid. HCl is a strong acid because in water solution it dissociates (nearly) completely into chloride ion and hydrogen protons (which are then solvated by water).


HCl+HX2OHX3OX++ClX


That is the reaction of hydrochloric acid with water. Note the one-way arrow; the reaction is a one way street. HCl is the acid; ClX is the conjugate base; water is the base and hydronium ion is the conjugate acid. In other words, this is the generalized reaction:


(strong) acid+baseconjugate  acid+conjugate  base


In bite-size pieces:


(strong) acidconjugate  base


and


baseconjugate  acid



Add the above two "half-reactions" together and you get a complete Brønsted acid/base reaction.


So back to the dissociation of HCl.


If this reaction (the reverse reaction) happened to a significant extent:


HCl+HX2OHX3OX++ClX


Then that would be antagonistic to the dissociation of HCl! HCl would no longer be nearly completely deprotonated in water solution since the reverse reaction is significant!


Therefore, we conclude that if one has a strong acid, then its conjugate base must be weak. The converse is also true; if an acid's conjugate base is weak, then the acid must be strong.


No comments:

Post a Comment

readings - Appending 内 to a company name is read ない or うち?

For example, if I say マイクロソフト内のパートナーシップは強いです, is the 内 here read as うち or ない? Answer 「内」 in the form: 「Proper Noun + 内」 is always read 「ない...